Comparison between Spark DataFrame vs DataSets

1. Objective

Recently, there are two new data abstractions released dataframe and datasets in apache spark. Now,  it might be difficult to understand the relevance of each one. Also, not easy to decide which one to use and which one not to. By keeping this points in mind this blog is introduced here, we will discuss both the APIs: spark dataframe and datasets on the basis of their features. We will learn complete comparison between DataFrame vs DataSets here.

In addition, we will also learn the usage of spark datasets and dataframes. But to understand all first, we need to know the brief introduction of dataframe vs datasets.

DataFrame vs DataSets

Comparison Between DataFrame vs DataSets

2. Introduction of Spark DataSets vs DataFrame

2.1. DataFrames

DataFrames gives a schema view of data basically, it is an abstraction. In dataframes, view of data is organized as columns with column name and types info. In addition, we can say data in dataframe is as same as the table in relational database.

As similar as RDD, execution in dataframe too is lazy triggered. Moreover, to allow efficient processing datasets is structure as a distributed collection of data. Spark also uses catalyst optimizer along with dataframes.

2.2. DataSets

In Spark, datasets are an extension of dataframes. Basically, it earns two different APIs characteristics, such as strongly typed and untyped. Datasets are by default a collection of strongly typed JVM objects, unlike dataframes. Moreover, it uses Spark’s Catalyst optimizer. For exposing expressions & data field to a query planner.

3. Comparison: Spark DataFrame vs DataSets, on the basis of Features

Let’s discuss the difference between apache spark Datasets &  spark DataFrame, on the basis of their features:

3.1. Spark Release

DataFrame-  In Spark 1.3 Release, dataframes are introduced.

DataSets-  In Spark 1.6 Release, datasets are introduced.

3.2. Data Formats

DataFrame-  Dataframes organizes the data in the named column. Basically, dataframes can efficiently process unstructured and structured data. Also, allows the Spark to manage schema.

DataSets-  As similar as dataframes, it also efficiently processes unstructured and structured data. Also, represents data in the form of a collection of row object or JVM objects of row. Through encoders, is represented in tabular forms.

3.3. Data Representation

DataFrame-  In dataframe data is organized into named columns. Basically,  it is as same as a table in a relational database.

DataSets-  As we know, it is an extension of dataframe API, which provides the functionality of type-safe, object-oriented programming interface of the RDD API. Also, performance benefits of the Catalyst query optimizer.

3.4. Compile-time type safety

DataFrame- There is a case if we try to access the column which is not on the table. Then, dataframe APIs does not support compile-time error.

DataSets- Datasets offers compile-time type safety.

3.5. Data Sources API

DataFrame- It allows data processing in different formats, for example, AVRO, CSV, JSON, and storage system HDFS, HIVE tables, MySQL.

DataSets- It also supports data from different sources.

3.6. Immutability and Interoperability

DataFrame- Once transforming into dataframe, we cannot regenerate a domain object.

DataSets- Datasets overcomes this drawback of dataframe to regenerate the RDD from dataframe. It also allows us to convert our existing RDD and dataframes into datasets.

3.7. Efficiency/Memory use

DataFrame- By using off-heap memory for serialization, reduce the overhead.

DataSets-  It allows to perform an operation on serialized data. Also, improves memory usage.

3.8. Serialization

DataFrame- In dataframe, can serialize data into off-heap storage in binary format. Afterwards, it performs many transformations directly on this off-heap memory.

DataSets-  In Spark, dataset API has the concept of an encoder. Basically, it handles conversion between JVM objects to tabular representation. Moreover, by using spark internal tungsten binary format it stores, tabular representation. Also, allows to perform an operation on serialized data and also improves memory usage.

3.9. Lazy Evolution

DataFrame- As same as RDD, Spark evaluates dataframe lazily too.

DataSets- As similar to RDD, and Dataset it also evaluates lazily.

3.10. Optimization

DataFrame- Through spark catalyst optimizer, optimization takes place in dataframe.

DataSets-  For optimizing query plan, it offers the concept of dataframe catalyst optimizer.

3.11. Schema Projection

DataFrame- Through the Hive meta store, it auto-discovers the schema. We do not need to specify the schema manually.

DataSets-  Because of using spark SQL engine, it auto discovers the schema of the files.

3.12. Programming Language Support

DataFrame-  In 4 languages like Java, Python, Scala, and R dataframes are available.

DataSets- Only available in Scala and Java.

3.13. Usage of Datasets and Dataframes

DataFrame-

  • If low-level functionality is there.
  • Also, if high-level abstraction is required.

DataSets-

  • For high-degree safety at runtime.
  • To take advantage of typed JVM objects.
  • Also, take advantage of the catalyst optimizer.
  • To save space.
  • It required faster execution.

4. Conclusion

As a result, we have seen that both dataframes and datasets in apache spark allow custom view and structure. Moreover, both offers high-level domain-specific operations. Also saves space, and executes at high speed. Hence, by analyzing the difference between dataframe vs datasets, we can select one out of dataframes or dataset that meets our requirements.

For learning Spark, refer this Spark books.

Reference – dataframe and datasets

Leave a comment.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *